Choosing the right tenant is one of the most important decisions a landlord makes. A reliable tenant pays on time, takes care of the apartment and gets along with neighbours. In Quebec, landlords have the right to check that a candidate can pay the rent and will respect the lease, but they must do so within the limits of privacy and human rights laws. Asking the wrong question can expose a landlord to a complaint, and collecting too much information can violate privacy rules.

This guide is written for Montreal landlords, but tenants will also find it useful to know what can legitimately be asked of them.

The legal framework

Three sets of rules frame tenant screening in Quebec:

  • The Charter of human rights and freedoms prohibits discrimination in the conclusion of a lease based on protected grounds.
  • Private sector privacy legislation limits the personal information a landlord may collect to what is necessary for the purpose, and requires consent and proper handling.
  • The Civil Code of Québec and the rules of the Tribunal administratif du logement (TAL) govern the lease itself, including what a landlord can require at signing.

Discrimination: grounds you cannot use

Under the Quebec Charter, a landlord cannot refuse to rent, impose different conditions or treat a candidate differently because of grounds such as race, colour, sex, gender identity or expression, pregnancy, sexual orientation, civil status, age (except as provided by law), religion, political convictions, language, ethnic or national origin, social condition, a handicap or the use of any means to palliate a handicap.

Some practical consequences:

Do not Why
Refuse families with children Discrimination based on civil status or family situation is prohibited
Refuse someone on social assistance as such Social condition is a protected ground
Ask about religion, origin or plans to have children These questions relate to protected grounds
Refuse a person using a guide dog or wheelchair Use of a means to palliate a handicap is protected
Advertise “no students” or “professionals only” based on stereotypes Can amount to discrimination based on age or social condition

You can, however, assess every candidate’s ability to pay and their history as a tenant, as long as you apply the same criteria to everyone.

What you can ask

A landlord can collect the information necessary to decide whether to rent to someone and to manage the lease, for example:

  • Name and contact information
  • Information needed to verify identity
  • Current and previous addresses, and references from previous landlords
  • Information to assess ability to pay: employer and income, or other sources of income
  • Consent to a credit check
  • Number of occupants (to check that the unit is suitable)
  • Whether the candidate has pets, if the lease or building rules address pets

What you should not ask

  • Social insurance number (SIN): it is not required to rent a dwelling, and you should not require it.
  • Bank account numbers or full bank statements as a routine requirement, beyond what is necessary to assess ability to pay.
  • Medical information or questions about disabilities.
  • Immigration status details beyond what is necessary, or questions about origin.
  • A copy of a passport or driver’s licence to keep, when simply seeing it is enough to verify identity.

The guiding principle is necessity: collect only what you truly need, keep it secure and destroy it when no longer needed.

Credit checks

A landlord can check a candidate’s credit with their consent. Explain why you need it and which agency you will use. If the candidate refuses, you may decide not to rent to them, but you cannot obtain their report without consent. Keep in mind that many newcomers and young adults have no Canadian credit history. Rather than excluding them, consider alternatives such as proof of employment, an employment contract, bank balance confirmation or references. Our article for tenants on renting without credit history describes what candidates can offer.

Deposits and guarantees

In Quebec, a landlord cannot require a security deposit. At the signing of the lease, the landlord can only require the first month’s rent (or the first payment period if it is shorter than a month). Asking for a deposit, a last month’s rent in advance or postdated cheques as a condition is not allowed. A guarantor (co-signer) is a different matter: it can be discussed, but should not be used in a discriminatory way. See security deposit rules in Quebec.

A fair, efficient screening process

  1. Write a clear listing: rent, what is included, move-in date, rules on pets and smoking. Avoid discriminatory wording.
  2. Use the same application form for everyone, limited to necessary information.
  3. Show the unit and answer questions; be transparent about the building.
  4. Verify identity by seeing an ID document, without keeping a copy unless necessary.
  5. Call references: previous landlord (ask about rent payment, condition of the unit, respect for neighbours) and employer.
  6. Do a credit check with written consent, if you use one.
  7. Apply the same criteria to every candidate and keep notes on why you chose one.
  8. Sign the mandatory TAL lease, fill in section G with the lowest rent paid in the previous twelve months, and give the tenant a copy within ten days.

Questions to ask previous landlords

  • How long did the tenant live in the unit?
  • Was the rent paid on time?
  • How was the condition of the apartment at the end of the lease?
  • Were there complaints from neighbours?
  • Would you rent to them again?

Keep in mind that a current landlord may give a positive reference to get rid of a difficult tenant, while a previous landlord has less reason to do so.

Protecting personal information

  • Store applications securely (locked cabinet or protected digital storage).
  • Limit access to people who need it.
  • Destroy the files of candidates you did not select after a reasonable period.
  • Do not share information with third parties without consent.

Red flags and scams targeting landlords

Some fraudsters target landlords too: fake employment letters, edited pay stubs, overpayment cheques with a request to refund the difference. Verify employers through publicly listed phone numbers, not those provided in the documents, and never refund an overpayment before the funds clear. See our article on rental scams.

Delegating screening

If you own several units or do not have time to manage applications, a property management company can handle listings, visits, screening, leases and follow-up. In Montreal, Kalfa offers property management services. You can also reach thousands of renters by listing your property on montreal.rent.

For tenants: what this means for you

As a candidate, you can refuse to give information that is not necessary, such as your SIN, and you can ask why a document is required. You can also prepare a strong file with references and proof of income. Our guide on how to stand out with a rental application explains how. If you believe you were refused for a discriminatory reason, you can contact the Commission des droits de la personne et des droits de la jeunesse.

A sample application form

Here is the kind of information a fair, privacy-respecting application form can include. Adapt it to your building and keep it identical for every candidate.

Section Fields
Contact Name, phone, email
Housing history Current address, previous address, contact information of current and previous landlords
Ability to pay Employer or source of income, approximate monthly income, contact for verification
Occupants Number of adults and children who will live in the unit
Lease details Desired move-in date, pets, parking needs
Consent Signed consent for reference checks and, if used, a credit check

Scoring candidates consistently

To make fair and defensible decisions, decide your criteria before reading applications, for example: rent-to-income ratio, positive references from a previous landlord, a stable source of income and a complete file. Apply them in the same order to everyone, and note the reason for your choice. This protects you if a candidate later claims discrimination.

Common mistakes landlords make

  • Asking for a SIN or a full bank statement by default.
  • Requiring a deposit or the last month’s rent in advance.
  • Writing “perfect for a single professional” or “no children” in the listing.
  • Choosing the first candidate who “seems nice” without calling references.
  • Keeping copies of ID documents for every visitor, including those not selected.
  • Forgetting to complete section G of the lease with the previous rent.

After you choose a tenant

Once you have selected a candidate, confirm your decision in writing and agree on the lease signing date. Fill in the mandatory TAL lease carefully, including the rent, the services included, section G and any building rules attached as an annex. Give the tenant a copy within ten days of signing. Inform the other candidates politely that the unit has been rented, and destroy the personal information you no longer need. Finally, plan a walk-through on move-in day and take dated photos with the tenant: it protects both of you and sets a respectful tone for the rest of the lease.

Frequently asked questions

Can a landlord refuse a tenant with bad credit?

A landlord can consider ability to pay and payment history, including credit information obtained with consent, as long as the same criteria apply to everyone.

Can a landlord ask how many people will live in the unit?

Yes. The number of occupants is relevant to the suitability of the dwelling. But refusing because the household includes children is prohibited.

Can a landlord ask for a guarantor?

A guarantor can be discussed, but requirements should be applied fairly and not used to exclude people for protected reasons.

Can I ask for the first and last month’s rent?

No. In Quebec, only the first month’s rent can be required in advance.

Official resources

See the Commission des droits de la personne et des droits de la jeunesse for discrimination in housing, the Commission d’accès à l’information for privacy, and the Tribunal administratif du logement for leases.