Many Montreal tenants sign leases with extra clauses written by the landlord: rules about pets, guests, painting, repairs or penalties. Some of these clauses are perfectly legal. Others go against the Civil Code of Québec and have no legal effect, even if you signed them. Knowing the difference helps you avoid conflicts and protect your rights. This guide explains the most common problematic clauses and what to do. It is general information, not legal advice.
The basic principle
Residential leases in Quebec are governed by the Civil Code of Québec, and many tenant protections are of public order. That means a clause that waives or limits these rights is without effect. Also, a clause that is abusive, meaning excessively and unreasonably detrimental to the tenant, can be cancelled or reduced. The official mandatory lease form, available from the Tribunal administratif du logement (TAL), already summarizes many rights. You can consult it and related information on the TAL website.
Common clauses that have no legal effect
1. Requiring post-dated cheques
A landlord cannot require post-dated cheques or another post-dated payment instrument for rent. A tenant can choose to provide them, but it cannot be imposed.
2. Requiring a large security deposit
Generally, a landlord cannot require more than the first month’s rent in advance, and security deposits are not allowed for residential leases. Read our guide to security deposits in Montreal.
3. Penalties far above the real damage
Clauses imposing fixed penalties, such as large fees for a late payment or for leaving early, can be considered abusive. Landlords can claim actual damages, but not arbitrary fines.
4. Waiving the right to maintain the lease
Tenants in Quebec generally have the right to stay in their dwelling, with exceptions such as repossession or eviction for specific reasons, which follow strict rules. A clause saying the tenant agrees to leave at the end of the lease without notice is without effect. See repossession and eviction rights.
5. Making the tenant responsible for all repairs
The landlord must deliver the dwelling in good habitable condition and make necessary repairs, except minor maintenance repairs that the tenant may be responsible for. A clause putting all repairs on the tenant is not valid. Read repairs and tenant rights.
6. Limiting the landlord’s liability for damage caused by the building
A landlord cannot exclude or limit liability for injury or damage caused by their fault or by the building’s defects.
7. Unlimited access to the apartment
Landlords must give notice before entering, except in emergencies, and visits follow specific rules on timing. A clause granting entry at any time is without effect. See landlord entry and privacy rules.
8. Banning lease transfer or sublet outright
Tenants have the right to assign or sublet, subject to giving notice and the landlord’s ability to refuse for a serious reason. A clause forbidding it in all cases is not valid. Read lease transfer and subletting.
9. Automatic rent increases without notice
For most leases, rent increases must follow the notice procedure, and tenants can refuse and let the TAL decide. A clause providing for automatic increases outside these rules may be without effect, except in specific situations such as some new buildings indicated in the lease. See rent increase notices.
10. Penalizing pregnancy, children or discrimination-based rules
Refusing to rent or imposing conditions based on discriminatory grounds, such as having children, is prohibited by the Quebec Charter of human rights and freedoms.
Clauses that are usually legal
- reasonable rules about noise, garbage and use of common areas;
- a no-pets clause in the lease, which is generally valid if agreed at signing; see renting with pets;
- a no-smoking clause, if included in the lease; see smoking and cannabis rules;
- building regulations given to the tenant before signing.
What to do if your lease has an illegal clause
- Do not panic: signing an illegal clause does not make it enforceable.
- Keep a copy of the lease and any building regulations.
- Discuss calmly with the landlord and refer to the official information from the TAL.
- Put requests in writing and keep records.
- Get help from a tenants’ rights committee or legal clinic if needed.
- File at the TAL if the dispute continues; see how to file a TAL claim.
Before you sign: a quick checklist
- Is the official TAL lease form used?
- Is section G completed with the previous rent? See section G explained.
- Are extra clauses clear and reasonable?
- Are inclusions (heating, appliances, parking) written down?
- Did you receive building regulations before signing?
Our pre-lease checklist covers more.
Other clauses that often cause disputes
Limits on guests
A landlord can set reasonable rules about the peaceful enjoyment of the building, but a clause that forbids any visitor or overnight guest goes too far. Tenants are entitled to receive visitors, as long as they do not disturb other occupants or change the use of the dwelling.
Fees for routine maintenance
Clauses that charge the tenant for repainting at the end of the lease, for regular carpet cleaning or for normal wear and tear are often contestable. A tenant must return the dwelling in the condition received, except for normal wear and tear and damage not caused by the tenant.
Bans on decoration
Reasonable rules on renovations are valid, but normal decoration, such as hanging pictures, is generally considered part of normal use. Ask before making changes such as painting walls, and get any permission in writing.
New charges not in the lease
Any service or charge must be agreed and written in the lease. A landlord cannot add new monthly fees during the lease without your agreement.
How abusive clauses are assessed
When a clause is challenged, the Tribunal administratif du logement looks at whether it is excessively and unreasonably detrimental to the tenant, or contrary to the rules of public order. The tribunal can cancel the clause or reduce the obligation it creates. Each case depends on its facts, so keep the lease, building rules, messages and photos that show what happened.
Sample wording to raise an issue
A short, polite written message often solves the problem. For example: “Hello, I noticed that clause 4 of our lease requires post-dated cheques. According to the information published by the Tribunal administratif du logement, this cannot be required. I propose to pay by bank transfer on the first of each month. Thank you for confirming.” Keep a copy of your message and of the reply.
New buildings and section F
The lease form includes a section concerning dwellings in recently built or converted buildings. In some cases, this allows the landlord to set rent increases without the usual TAL control for a limited period, under conditions written in the lease. If this section is checked, read it carefully before signing and ask questions, because it affects your future rent. Official explanations are available on the TAL website.
FAQ
If I signed an illegal clause, am I bound by it?
No. A clause contrary to public-order rules has no legal effect, even if signed.
Can a landlord refuse to rent to me because I have children?
No. This is discrimination prohibited by the Quebec Charter.
Can a landlord ask for post-dated cheques?
They can ask, but cannot require them.
This article is general information and not legal advice. Consult the TAL or a legal professional for your situation.
